WILLIAM LITTLE
William Little (fl. Philadelphia, ca. 1798-1801), a composer, was co-recipient with William Smith of a copyright on shape notation (Philadelphia, 10 March 1798; see below, under Smith), and he and Smith were the first to print music in shape-notes. Little's career remains obscure. Printers named William Little worked in Philadelphia (1802-3) and New York (1808-9). And a William Little (b. Newburyport, Mass., 7 April 1771; d. Louisville, Ky., 2 Aug. 1836), who was building coaches in Charlestown, Massachusetts, in 1797, moved to Philadelphia shortly thereafter as a maker of metal ornaments and moldings. It is not known whether any of these was the musical William Little, but the latter's dates seem right, and the repertory of The Easy Instructor indicates that the compilers were New Englanders.
Bio-bib, Grove. Also Crawford 1968, p. 167-76; Little 1882, p. 268; Lowens 1964, ch. 6, especially p. 122 & n.
THE EASY INSTRUCTOR, 1801-10
A letter of 20 Feb. 1806 from Nathan Jones to Andrew Law (Law Papers) reveals that the system of shape notation used in Little and Smith's The Easy Instructor, the first shape-note tunebook, was devised 'as early as 1782 or 1783.' Law's reply, 11 March 1806, identifies as the inventor 'Mr. Colloney,' who proves upon investigation to be John Connelly of Philadelphia. (See Crawford 1968, p. 175.) Connelly is listed as a shopkeeper in the Philadelphia city directory for 1785, and later directories through 1817 list him, always mentioning his business. Directories of 1818-25 name him as a 'gentleman,' indicating his retirement from business. The 1828 directory lists his widow, indicating that he died, probably in Philadelphia, sometime in the period 1825-28. On 10 March 1798 Connelly granted 'to Mr. Willm Little and to Mr. William Smith, the sole and exclusive right to publish' music in his shape notation. (See Smith, The Easy Instructor, Part II, [1803], No. 471, below.) Copyright was granted 15 June 1798 to Edward Stammers and William Little, proprietors of a tunebook to be called The Easy Instructor. On 15 Aug. 1798 a 'Committee appointed by the Uranian Society of Philadelphia, to examine a singing-book, intitled "The Easy Instructor," by William Little' filed a favorable report, proving that the members had seen at least a manuscript copy. However, the work seems not to have been published until 1801. When it did appear, William Smith was named co-compiler with Little. The unusually successful career of Little and Smith's The Easy Instructor is described in Lowens 1964, ch. 6, and a detailed checklist of editions is given there as Appendix B. Letters A-H, by which Lowens designates pre-1811 editions, follow Shaw-Shoemaker numbers in the entries below. In 1803 and again in 1806 William Smith compiled and brought out The Easy Instructor Part II, an entirely separate work.
The Easy Instructor, [1st ed., 1801]
ASMI 363
The Easy Instructor, or A New Method of Teaching Sacred Harmony. Containing the rudiments of music on an improved plan, wherein the naming and timing the notes are familiarized to the weakest capacity. - With a choice collection of psalm tunes and anthems from the most celebrated authors, with a number composed in Europe and America, entirely new; suited to all the metres sung in the different churches in the United States. Published for the use of singing societies in general, but more particularly for those who have not the advantage of an instructor. By William Little & William Smith[.] Copy right secured according to act of Congress.
1 p.l., 105 p. 14 x 23.5 cm. T-p., p. 12-105 engraved. Music printed in 4-shape notation. p. 12 repeated in pagination; 1st p. 12 is typeset, 2d engraved.
[1801.] Endorsement from Uranian Society in this and all issues through 1810 dated Philadelphia, 15 Aug. 1798. The Philadelphia Repository and Weekly Register, 22 Aug. 1801, advertises The Easy Instructor as having 'just made its appearance in this city. p.l. Recto, t-p.; verso blank; p. [1]-[2], 'Index'; p. [3], 'Advertisement'; p. [3]-4, endorsement from Uranian Society; p. 4-8, 'Preface'; p. 8-12, instructions; p. 12-16, rudiments; p. 17-105, music. 'As the Authors are well aware, that whatever has the appearance of novelty is, from this very circumstance, in danger of meeting with an unfavorable reception; they request nothing more than a critical observation of the certificate annexed, and an impartial examination of the method proposed, being willing to submit the merit of the performance to the determination of the candid and judicious. As the introduction of the four singing syllables, by characters, shewing, at sight, the names of the notes, mayperhaps [sic] be considered as subjecting those who who are taught in this manner to difficulty in understanding other books, without this assistance. The authors would just observe, that if pupils are made acquainted with the principles here laid down, the objection will be found, by experience, more specious, than solid. To this it might be added, that in the old way, there are not less than seven different ways of applying the four singing syllables to the lines and spaces, which is attended with great difficulty: But this difficulty is entirely removed, upon the present plan; and we know of no objection to this plan, unless that it is not in use; which objection is no abjection at all, or at least, cannot be decisive, as this would give currency, to the entire rejection and exclusion of all improvements whatever. And as the novelty of a singing-book rendered so easy, from its improvements, that any person of a tolerable voice might actually learn the art of psalmody without an instructor, if they could but obtain the sounds of the eight notes, which has led its advocates to request a publication of the same. We have, therefore, the pleasure to inform the public, that since subscriptions have been in circulation, for this book, we have been honored with upwards of three thousand subscribers: In consequence of which, we flatter ourselves, that this book will meet with a kind reception.' (Advertisement in full.) 'The Committee Appointed By The Uranian Society of Philadelphia, To Examine A Singing-Book, Intitled "The Easy Instructor," By William Little, Report, That having carefully examined the same, they find it contains a well digested system of principles and rules, and a judicious collection of tunes: And from the improvement of having only four significant characters, indicating, at sight, the names of the notes, and a sliding rule for timing the same, this book is considered easier to be learned than any we have seen.' (Extract from endorsement.) 'It must be confessed, that where pleasure is the sole attention [in psalmody], the motive is of an inferior nature. But is it not a commendable policy to promote regular attendance upon places of worship, by any means that are not reprehensible? Will not the most beneficial consequences probably ensue? Is there not every reason to expect that . . . they who come to sing may learn to pray-that they whose only wish it was to be entertained, may find themselves instructed and improved? Such is the happy tendency of well regulated song in the house of God; but alas! how seldom is this part of the service accompanied with its proper effect. . . . Too often does a disgraceful silence prevail to the utter neglect of this duty-too often are dissonance and discord substituted for the charms of melody and harmony, and the singing performed in a way so carelessly and indecently, that, as [an eminent] writer observes, "Instead of elevating our devotions to the most divine and delightful sensations, it awakens our regret, and touches all the springs of uneasiness within us." But is this owing to causes that cannot be removed, or doth it not imply reproach and blame? Will not truth oblige us to confess, that the fault rests not in the want of natural taste and abilities, nor of sufficient leisure, but in great carelessness and neglect? Moderate attention and application would surmount every difficulty, and lead to a suitable proficiency in this happy art. An exercise so pleasing and attractive, seems only to want regulation and method. (Extract from Preface.)
105 compositions, incl. I anthem & 2 set-pieces, for 4 voices; some w. full text, others textless or w. textual incipits only. Attribs. to Babcock, Billings (3), Brooks, Brown (2) [MEAR is non-American, WILLIAMSTOWN is American], Brownson (3), Bull, Bunister, Carpenter, Caswell, Coan (2), Cowling (2), Davis (5), Deolph, Edson (4), Goff, Griswold (4), Hall (2), Huntington, Ives, Johnson, N. Little (5), W. Little (4), Morgan (6), Peck (3), I. E. Porter, Pratt, Reed (6), Russ, Shumway (2), Smith [American], Stammers, Stevenson, Stout, Swan (5), Wand, Ward (6), West (2), Wetmore, Williams (3), Wood (2). 41 1st pr. claimed, 29 identified (ALVAH, AMERICA'S LAMENTATION, AMWELL, Anthem: I will sing; CALDWELL, CANAAN, CAROLINA, CONAJOHARY, ESSEX, FRANKLIN, FUNERAL, HILLSBOROUGH, HOPEWELL, INDIAN BARD, LANCASTER, LISBON, MEDITATION, MIFFLIN, NATIVITY, NORTH ORANGE, PSALM 40, SAPPHICK ODE, SOLEMNITY, SOLITUDE, STERLING, STILLWATER, SUNDAY, WASHINGTON NEW, WAS-TINA), also I 1st Am. pr. (Avon). 198 American compositions, 7 non-American (85 attrib. Americans, 13 traced; 5 attrib. non-Americans, 2 traced [MOUNT VERNON, WELLS]).
27 Core Repertory.
Not in Shaw-Shoemaker (no copy on Readex). Lowens Aa. CtHC*.
PREFATORY NOTE: Except for one tiny detail this issue is identical with the main entry. In the tune STAFFORD, p. 87, a key signature present in the earlier issue is removed. It can still be seen faintly in the DLC copy.
ASMI 363A
The Easy Instructor . . . Copy right secured according to act of Congress.
1 p.l., 105 p. T-p., p. 12-105 engraved. p. 12 repeated in pagination.
[1802.] New York Chronicle Express, 25 Nov. 1802, advertises work as 'this day . . . published' by G. & R. Waite, New York. Copyright granted, 10 Dec. 1802, District of New York, to William Little (NY 1:150). Since this issue followed the one described in the main entry, it is claimed here as the one published and copyrighted in New York in 1802. Contents same as main entry. Engraved portion printed from same plates as main entry.
Music same as main entry.
S2545 (MWA). Lowens Ab. CtHT-W (lacks all before p. 13, all after p. 100), DLC (lacks engraved p. 12-13), MWA* (p. [1-2] mutilated), RPB (2).
NOTE: S2544 reproduces a typographically-printed 112-p. issue owned by PPL; it dates from some time after 1810.
The Easy Instructor, [2d ed.], 1805
ASMI 364
The Easy Instructor By William Little and William Smith. Albany: printed by Charles R. and George Webster, and Daniel Steele, proprietors of the copy-right; and sold at Webster's bookstore, corner of State and Pearl-Streets, and at Steele's bookstore, near the Court-house, in Court-Street. 1805.
108 p. p. 13-108 engraved; p. 108 signed by [H.W.] Snyder. Music printed in 4-shape notation.
P. [1], t-p.; p. [2], 'Index'; p. [3], 'Advertisement' & endorsement from Uranian Society; p. 4-12, 'Preface'; p. 13-17, rudiments; p. 18-108, music.
102 compositions, incl. 2 anthems & 3 set-pieces, for 4 voices (a few for 3); most w. full text, some textless or w. textual incipits only. Attribs. to Austin, Billings (4), Bronson (2), Brunson, Brown (2), Bull, Carpenter, Castle, Caswell, Coan (2), Cowling, Davis (4), Deolph, Edson (3), French, Goff (2), Griswold (4), Hall (2), Handel, Howel, Ives, Johnson, N. Little (3), W. Little (2), Madun (2), Morgan (5), Munson, Peck (2), J. E. Potter, Reed (6), Russ, Sansun [Tans'ur], Shumway (3), Stevenson, Stone (2), Swan (3), Ward (4), West (2), Wetmore, Williams (3), Wood. 1 1st pr. identified (SCHENECTADY). 88 American compositions, 14 non-American (73 attrib. Americans [1 wrongly, MOUNT VERNON], 16 traced; 9 attrib. non-Americans, 5 traced [IRISH, LITTLE MARLBOROUGH, MARTIN'S LANE, MOUNT VERNON, OLD 100]).
34 Core Repertory.
S8794 (NN). Lowens B. NN*.
The Easy Instructor, [4th ed.], 1807
ASMI 366
The Easy Instructor . . . By William Little and William Smith. Albany: printed by Websters & Skinner and Daniel Steele, proprietors of the copy-right; and sold at their respective bookstores, at the corner of State and Pearl-Streets, and a few doors south of the Court-house, in Court-Street. 1807.
8, 13-108 p. p. 13-108 engraved.
P. [1], t-p.; p. [2], 'Index'; p. [3], 'Advertisement & endorsement from Uranian Society; p. [4]-8, 'Preface'; p. 13-17, rudiments; p. 18-108, music. Engraved portions printed from same plates as [2d ed.].
Music same as [2d ed.].
Not in Shaw-Shoemaker. Lowens Dd. NcWsM* (2), NjR.
PREFATORY NOTE: This issue, otherwise identical with the main entry, shows small typo-graphical variations with it. At the foot of p. [3], the main entry contains the phrase 'which is submitted to Edward Stammers and Richard T. Leech'; the word 'to' is missing from the parallel place in this issue. Also, in the caption on p. 7, this issue has a misprint 'Instuctor."
ASMI 366A
The Easy Instructor . . . 1807.
8, 13-108 p. p. 13-108 engraved.
Contents same as main entry. (No. 364). Engraved portions printed from same plates as [2d ed.]
Music same as [2d ed.].
S12933 (NN). Lowens Db. DLC, ICN, MWA (lacks all after p. 106), MiU-C*, NN, PPIPT, WaU.
The Easy Instructor, [5th ed.], 1808
ASMI 367
The Easy Instructor . . . 1808.
8, 13-108 p. p. 13-108 engraved.
Contents same as [2d ed.] (No. 364). Engraved portions printed from same plates as [2d ed.].
Music same as [2d ed.].
S15437 (MWA). Lowens E. CtHT-W, IU, MWA, MiU-C*, MOKU, NNUT, NcWsM (front matter inc.).
The Easy Instructor, [6th ed., 1808-10]
ASMI 368
The Easy Instructor; or, A New Method of Teaching Sacred Harmony. Containing I. The rudiments of music on an improved plan, wherein the naming and timing of the notes are familiarized to the weakest capacity. II. A choice collection of psalm tunes and anthems, from the most celebrated authors, with a number composed in in [sic] Europe and America, entirely new; suited to all the metres sung in the different churches in the United States. Published for the use of singing societies in general, but more particularly for those who have not the advantage of an instructor. By William Little and William Smith. Printed, typographically, at Albany, by Websters & Skinner and Daniel Steele, (proprietors of the copy-right,) and sold at their respective bookstores, at the corner of State and Pearl-Streets, and a few doors south of the old city-hall, in Court-Street; by T. & J. Swords, Evert Duyckinck and William Falconer, New-York; Mathew Carey, Johnson & Warner, William W. Woodward and Hopkins & Earl, Philadelphia; and Increase Cook, New-Haven.
104 p. Music printed in 4-shape notation.
[1808-10.] The firm of Hopkins & Earl, mentioned as a seller on the t-p., existed only from 15 Feb. 1808 to 1 Feb. 1810, so the book was published between those dates. Since an edition dated 1808 on its t-p. had already appeared, 1809 seems the most likely year of issue. However, the Albany Balance & New-York State Journal, 6 Feb. 1810, advertised a 'new edition' as just published, and this may be it. p. [1], t-p.; p. [2], 'Index'; p. [3], 'Advertisement' & endorsement from Uranian Society; p. [4]-8, 'Preface'; p. 9-12, rudiments; p. 13-104, music; p. 104, note: 'Van Benthuysen & Wood, Typographers.'
95 compositions, incl. 3 anthems & 4 set-pieces, for 4 voices, a few for 3; full text. Attribs. to Austin, Belknap, Billings (4), W. Billings (2), Brown (2), Bronson, Brunson (2), Bull (5), Carpenter, Castle (2), Chandler (2), Coan, Deolph, Doolittle, Edson (3), French, Gillet, Goff, Griswold, Handel, Hibbert, Uri K. Hill, Holden (2), Holdrad, A. Lane, W. Little, M. Luther, Madun (3), Mead [Read], Morgan (3), Munson, Olmsted (2), Parmeter, Reed (5), Sansun [Tans'ur], Shumway (3), Stevenson, Stone (2), Swan (5), Ward (2), Wetmore (2), G. Williams, Wood. 15 1st pr. identified (BALLSTOWN, CRUCIFIXION, PIERMONT, PSALMS 23 & 29), also 2 1st Am. pr. (BABEL, PROVIDENCE). 174 American compositions, 18 non-American, 3 unidentified [BABEL, CHRISTIAN SONG, PROVIDENCE] (66 attrib. Americans, 8 traced [BRENTWOOD, FRIENDSHIP, JUDGMENT, NEW JERUSALEM, NORWICH, OCEAN, REPENTANCE, SHARON]; 10 attrib. non-Americans, 8 traced).
41 Core Repertory.
S17921 (dated [1809?], listed wrongly as having 112 p.) (no copy on Readex). Lowens F. DLC, MiU-C*, NcWsM, NN.
The Easy Instructor, [7th ed., 1810]
ASMI 369
The Easy Instructor By William Little and William Smith. Printed, typographically, at Albany, by Websters & Skinner and Daniel Steele . . . in Court-Street; by T. & J. Swords, Everet Duyckinck and William Falconer, New-York; Wm. J. M'Cartee, Schenectady; A. Seward, Utica; Tracy & Bliss, Lansingburgh; Parker & Bliss, Troy; and Increase Cook, New-Haven. Van Benthuysen & Newton, typographers.
104 p. Music printed in 4-shape notation.
[1810.] Could not have appeared before 8 May 1810, when Van Benthuysen & Newton went into business. Contents same as [6th ed.] (No. 368).
94 compositions, incl. 3 anthems & 4 set-pieces, for 4 voices, a few for 3; full text. Attribs. to Austin, Belknap, Billings (4), W. Billings (2), Brown (2), Bronson (2), Brunson (2), Bull (5), Castle (2), Chandler (2), Coan, Deolph, Doolittle, Edson (3), French, Gillet, Goff, Griswold, Handel, Hibbert, Uri K. Hill, Holden (2), Holdrad, A. Lane, M. Luther, Madun (3), Mead [Read], Morgan (3), Munson, Olmsted (2), Parmeter, Reed (5), Sansun [Tans'ur], Shumway (3), Stevenson, Stone (2), Swan (5), Ward (2), Wetmore (2), G. Williams, Wood. No 1st pr. identified. 173 American compositions, 18 non-American, 3 unidentified [BABEL, CHRISTIAN SONG, PROVIDENCE] (64 attrib. Americans, 9 traced [add MOUNT SION to list in No. 368]; 10 attrib. non-Americans, 8 traced).
41 Core Repertory.
S20575 (MWA). Lowens G. CtHC, DLC (b.w. Christmas Anthem & Read, The Columbian Harmonist, 4th ed., 1810), ICN, MWA*, N, NNUT (2), NRU-Mus, NcWsM, NjR, RPB.
The Easy Instructor, [8th ed., 1810?]
ASMI 370
The Easy Instructor. By William Little and William Smith. Printed, typographically, at Albany, by Websters & Skinner and Daniel Steele . . . Troy; Increase Cook, New-Haven, and M. Cary, Philadelphia. Van Benthuysen & Newton, typographers.
104 p. Music printed in 4-shape notation.
[1810?] Lowens 1964, p. 299, explains: 'While it is theoretically possible that Ed. H [this issue] could have been issued in 1811, since George Newton did not die until November 20 of that year, it is more likely that it appeared in the previous year in view of the fact that E. Lewis (mentioned for the first time in the list of agents for Ed. I [1811]) apparently was in business for himself in Newburgh only after January, 1811. Furthermore, M. Car[e]y of Philadelphia, here listed for the first time, sent a receipt to the firm of Websters & Skinner for books received on November 29, 1810, according to the Carey papers.' Contents same as [6th ed.] (No. 368).
Music same as [7th ed.] (No. 369).
Not in Shaw-Shoemaker (no copy on Readex). Lowens H. MiU-C*, NjPT.
NOTE: Lowens 1964, p. 292-310, prints a detailed checklist of editions and issues, including those that appeared after 1810. None of the 13 Albany issues printed in the period 1811-18 has a title-page date, and it would be redundant to reproduce the complicated means by which Lowens dates these issues. Albany editions continued to appear as late as 1831. In addition, The Easy Instructor was printed in Utica, N.Y. (1818, 1820) and in Cincinnati, Ohio (1819). Lowens describes, in all, 34 different issues of The Easy Instructor.
ASMI pp. 437-444.